Pete N6QW had this very interesting video about Software Defined Radio on his blog. Thanks to G3WGV for putting this presentation together.
It is very interesting, but — for me — it is also troubling. I think something important is being missed in this discussion. You have to listen carefully, but if you do the thing being missed becomes apparent.
Like many others, G3WGV asserts that very soon, 100 percent of commercial radios will be SDR. Traditional superhet radios will be a thing of the past.
OK, but I will make a parallel assertion: Looking ahead, I think 100 percent of TRULY homebrewed rigs will be HDR.
Of course, this really just comes down to how you define “homebrew.” I’m a traditionalist here. I think of homebrewing as actually building — from discrete components — all the stages that send or receive radio signals. By my definition, I don’t think you can really “homebrew” an SDR radio. Taking an ADC chip and connecting it to a computer running SDR software is not — by my definition — homebrew. Even if you wrote the software yourself, writing code is not the same as wiring up all the stages that go into a superhet-style transceiver.
There were a few lines in G3WGV’s talk that seemed to confirm this difference: The SDR radio is defined as a “server.” Commercial manufacturers like SDR because they can use the same components that go into cell phones (exactly — and people will soon have the same relationship with these “radios” that we have with their cell phones).
I kind of grimaced when G3WGV described the two sets of users of SDR technology: the “early adopters” who are “technology enthusiasts”, and the “pragmatists” who don’t care what’s in the box — they just want to talk on it. I think “pragmatist” is a nice way of saying “appliance operator.” Even the “early adopters” are pretty far from the world of traditional homebrew. And for me that gets to the point that is being missed in all this — this shift away from hardware is also a shift away from homebrew.
But hey, this is a hobby. To each is own! Have it your way. For myself, I plan to continue with the hardcore, radical fundamentalist, hardware-defined, discrete component, fully analog homebrew radio. This morning I am attempting to stabilize a cap and coil VFO. And I’m liking it. As the world shifts to SDR, I look forward to the appearance on e-Bay of massive quantities of old forsaken HDR rigs. We will buy them for pennies on the dollar and use the parts for new HDR Superhet rigs.
Viva E. Howard Armstrong! Viva!




















